Why Kashmiri Pandits and Muslims Can Never Be Friends Again – OpEd

What would it be like for a Jew if a German were to say to him, “We had a little fall out sometime back but let’s forget it and makeup.” Or closer home, a Pakistani Hindu father whose daughter was kidnapped, converted and married off to a Muslim man is asked to come and hug the family to make up over a ‘little misunderstanding’.

Justice For Nirbhaya, But Don’t Forget The Unpardonable Brutality Against Sarla

The above seems to be the idea behind making of the movie ‘Shikara’ by Mr. Chopra when he says that Kashmiri Pandits and Kashmiri Muslims had a ‘little fallout’ and it is time to make up now.

‘Making up’ should be easy. The ball lies in the Kashmiri Pandit’s court now. It is he who has to show his magnanimity by accepting that it was only a ‘little fall out’. Hasn’t the Kashmiri Muslim been waiting with open arms all this while?

A strategy used in school from time immemorial between two fighting children. The teacher here Mr. Chopra has to be obeyed. After all, doesn’t he know the best. And Kashmiri Pandits have been easy to manage so far according to many. A few tears shed here and there and they melt.

Mr. Chopra’s only consolation should be that most of his ilk in Bollywood would share his mindset and empathize with his reasons. Financed by the seculars, the Bhais of the world and now threatened by the rise of Hindu awareness, films have to made, scripts have to be written so that the movie-going Hindu doesn’t realize how his ancestors have been treated in history. The word ‘secularism’ fitted the bill very well so far. It is no longer working. So, let’s admit to a ‘little fall out’ here and there that may have happened in the past.

30 Years In Exile: Time For Kashmiri Pandits To Wake-Up & Reclaim Their Holy-Land

Art, we are reminded has no boundaries. Provided the film is from Bollywood and the theme includes Hindu culture and has scenes between Hindu deities and heroes. There is a formula in it too. The Hindu has to be shown as responsible for his own victimization while other Hindus ridicule, criticize him and an angelic Abrahamic wise man comes to correct him, show him the true path. From ‘Deewar’, ‘Sholay’ or ‘PK’ to the present, it hasn’t failed.

Eighty years ago, the movie ‘Gone with the wind’ showed the world a romantic South of America where beautiful girls of plantation owners danced in white skirts while admiring slaves served lemonades to them. Who would know how horrendous was slavery after that?

Forty years ago, Richard Attenborough, the British director, couldn’t find a single Brown skinned Indian to play Gandhi in his film and settled on Ben Kingsley, the White man. He said he could not find anyone in India who could play the great leader. The message was clear. Gandhi was difficult for an Indian actor to play on screen. When someone asked him how a White man that too a Britisher, could get under the skin of Gandhi, understand what colonialism and its humiliation meant to him, his answer was simple, “It doesn’t make a difference.”

The underlying meaning was simple. The White man being superior can understand the Brown one so well that it is not a problem to enact him. He didn’t answer if the reverse would be true.

Why Return of Kashmir Pandits is Nearly Impossible Despite All The Hoopla

In the movie ‘Shikara’, the lead characters have been chosen to be non-Hindus. The Director if asked may give a similar explanation. “What is the problem if non-Hindus enact the role? It is acting after all.” The Kashmiri pandits would be told and if there is a ‘little fall out’, no pun intended, it can be taken care of easily. The Kashmiri Pandits are riding high with the abrogation of Article 370, the Hindus with Ram Janma Bhumi. They will get over it soon.

To add emphasis, the Director in a choked voice said he made it in Kashmir with Kashmiri Muslims watching and helping him. This transformation of heart by an entire population surely must rank as one of the greatest in history and must be researched upon. Another reason why Kashmiri Pandits must give up their anger?

Modi, Xi-Jinping, Aung San Suu Kyi – The Rise and Rise Of Asian Nationalism?

OpEd Shared With EurAsian Times. Penned By: Rajat Mitra

Does Not Represent the View of the EurAsian Times